Amazon and Ancient Tribe Face Off Over Cape Town Headquarters – Yahoo Finance

(Bloomberg) — On the outskirts of Cape Town, at the base of Table Mountain and set back from a tangle of freeways, the Liesbeek and Black rivers meet in a small stretch of marshland. The 37-acre plot isn’t pristine — it lies next to a railyard and was until recently home to a golf course […]

(Bloomberg) — On the outskirts of Cape Town, at the base of Table Mountain and set back from a tangle of freeways, the Liesbeek and Black rivers meet in a small stretch of marshland. The 37-acre plot isn’t pristine — it lies next to a railyard and was until recently home to a golf course — but for centuries, this land has been sacred ground for the Khoisan, a southern African tribe that traces its lineage back more than 100,000 years. In the near future, if all goes to plan, it will be the site of Amazon’s next regional headquarters.
Most Read from Bloomberg
Is Putin Finally Getting Smart About His Ukraine Disaster?
Elon Musk’s Tesla Share Sales Approach the $40 Billion Mark
Powell Says Fed Still Has a ‘Ways to Go’ After Half-Point Hike
Dollar Rallies as Risk-Off Tone Takes Stocks Lower: Markets Wrap
To many local First Nations peoples, news of the project came as an unhappy surprise. Since approval for the e-commerce giant’s $250 million office complex on the 150,000 square-meter site was granted, groups aligned with the Khoisan to oppose the project have tried to derail construction. On a near-monthly basis, dozens of protestors have gathered on the steps of the High Court in Cape Town with signs reading “Concrete will never be our heritage,” and “No means no.” They’ve filed petitions and lawsuits, appealed to media and lawmakers, and forced Capetonians to reckon with the uncomfortable question of whether they’re willing to prioritize economic development over the fight to recognize indigenous land rights in South Africa.
“It’s almost a case of history repeating itself,” said a Khoisan chief Bradley Van Sitters, who also goes by the name Hyi!Gaeb!Gorallgaullaes, the exclamation points representing the clicks in the tribe’s language. “A lot of our people’s blood has been spilled here.”
For its part, Amazon has been working with the developer to accommodate the Khoi and San tribes, which are often referred to collectively. In collaboration with Khoisan members who support the project, the company has announced plans to build a heritage center which will include a garden, a media area, and roads and pathways with Khoisan names.
With the economy stalling, Amazon also brings the promise of jobs and development in a city that desperately needs them. Unemployment is above 30% in South Africa, and nearly 27% in Cape Town. City government representatives say that the project will indirectly create jobs for 19,000 people, including more than 5,200 construction workers. Cape Town’s leaders are thrilled with the arrangement.
Although Amazon delivery services aren’t yet available in South Africa, the e-commerce giant has long had a presence in the country. It has kept offices in Cape Town for about 18 years, and the purpose of the Liesbeek hub is to consolidate the estimated 3,000-plus employees already in the city with another 5,000 or more to be hired in the next few years. This is part of a broader retail expansion into sub-Saharan Africa. Amazon Web Services recently opened offices in Johannesburg and Lagos, and according to people familiar with the matter who do not want to be identified as plans are not public, Amazon intends to roll out online delivery in South Africa and in Nigeria as early as next year.
None of these ambitions, however, rely on the Cape Town headquarters, which is nicknamed Project Zola, according to a bid proposal seen by Bloomberg. “The campus is a nice-to-have rather than a have-to-have,” said Arthur Goldstuck, a technology analyst and managing director of World Wide Worx.
That “nice-to-have” hasn’t come easily. In Cape Town, litigation began almost as soon as the project became public. Protestors scored an early victory against Amazon in March, when the High Court in Cape Town ordered Liesbeek Leisure to temporarily stop work, ruling that “the core consideration is the issue of proper and meaningful consultation with all affected First Nations Peoples.”
It wasn’t the first time Amazon encountered obstacles when trying to set up shop outside the U.S. Plans to build large logistics hubs in France were scrapped on at least four occasions in the past 18 months due to political, environmental and financial concerns. Earlier this year, the company was blocked from building a 76,200-square-meter warehouse near the eastern French city of Belfort on the grounds that the proposal for the project did not include “compensatory measures to offset the destruction of wetlands.”
In the Liesbeek case, however, the decision didn’t stick. The court sided with the company on appeal and dismissed claims that the development would threaten the site’s cultural legacy. As part of the development, $2.2 million (38 million rand) will be spent on environmental rehabilitation, the ruling went on to suggest that “development might enhance the land’s resources.” Construction on the site continued, though nobody can say for sure when it will be completed.
To Tauriq Jenkins, head of the Goringhaicona Khoi Khoin Indigenous Traditional council, an organization that represents some of the groups opposed to the site, the decision made little sense. “How can you build a heritage center on top of the history being destroyed?”
What might be the opposition’s last chance to stop the project now comes down to proving that stakeholders were not properly consulted. A date for the review hearing hasn’t been scheduled, but optimism is running low. Without “the deep pockets our opponents have,” said Leslie London, a professor at the University of Cape Town who has been involved in the case, the groups have been “outmanoeuvred legally.”
Amazon’s spokespeople in South Africa, Europe and the US declined to respond when contacted multiple times for comment. The site’s developer responded to queries.
Both the city and river valley have complicated histories. Europeans arrived in what is now Cape Town in the 15th century, and over the next several hundred years, local populations were brutally subjected to the rise of the slave trade, the introduction of apartheid, and government efforts to limit Black property ownership. When the Dutch settled along the Liesbeek in the 17th century, parcels of the valley were allocated to farmers and cut off from the Khoisan. It has mostly remained private land ever since. In recent years, the site has been used “as a private golf driving range, restaurant, bar and tarmac parking lot,” according to Liesbeek Leisure Properties Trust, the developer overseeing the Amazon project.
The current saga has led some to wonder why Amazon chose this site in the first place. “When it was announced that the Liesbeek Leisure Properties Trust was the preferred bidder to construct the Amazon headquarters on the River Club site, I was very surprised,” architect Derick Henstra, who advised one of the short-listed firms on the project, said in an affidavit filed as part of the case. “Both Amazon and the LLPT must have been conscious that selecting the site carried with it the risk of substantial delays.” In response, the developer said that “there was no reason to believe there would be delays or legal challenges to what is ostensibly an attempt to breathe life into a dilapidated space,” and added that it had all the necessary approvals to move ahead.
The project has also become a public relations headache. While many Cape Town residents are excited by the opportunities Amazon can offer (both in terms of jobs and midnight shopping binges) others have been put off by how the multinational handled this process. Ryan Dick, a software developer who lives in Cape Town, said he doesn’t “see how putting thousands of tons of concrete on top of a wetland is saving anything.” Another Capetonian, Sarah Driver-Jowitt, said that while she understood why Amazon Web Services wanted to centralize, she thought the site was “not an appropriate one.” Nadia Vatalidis, a human resources specialist, was sanguine about the controversy. Although any project has its downsides, she said, South Africa needs the jobs and investment.
One silver lining may be that the controversy has increased awareness around the Khoisan. In recent years, South Africa’s President Cyril Ramaphosa has signed legislation to acknowledge First Nations governance structures and established an advisory panel to address questions of land restitution. The Khoisan and others have also called on South Africa’s Heritage Resources Agency to declare the Liesbeek River Valley a heritage site. That wouldn’t stop construction, but it could delay it by two years.
As the Khoisan chief Van Sitters observed, fights over land have long moved off the battlefields and now happen in court.
For now, protestors say they will continue their efforts. Standing on the edge of the construction site one morning in October, Jenkins, the indigenous council leader, shook his head at the scene. “We want this development stopped,” he said over sounds of hammering and drilling. “We don’t want this concrete monstrosity here. This is sacred terrain.”
Most Read from Bloomberg Businessweek
Long Covid’s Effects Go Beyond Respiratory Issues
AmEx Hooked Big Spenders and Regained the Throne With a Pricier Platinum Card
A Racist Tweet Wasn’t the Only Problem at Elite London Firm
Elon Musk’s Twitter Is a Shakespearean Psychodrama Set in Silicon Valley
TikTok’s Problem Child Has 7 Million Followers and One Proud Mom
©2022 Bloomberg L.P.
Related Quotes
(Bloomberg) — Inc. faces a $280 million lawsuit from a Vietnamese manufacturer of warehouse storage systems that alleges the e-commerce giant abruptly scaled back orders after online spending growth cooled this year, leaving the manufacturer saddled with excess production capacity and raw materials.Most Read from BloombergIs Putin Finally Getting Smart About His Ukraine Disaster?Elon Musk’s Tesla Share Sales Approach the $40 Billion MarkPowell Says Fed Still Has a ‘Ways to Go’ After
Which? research reveals two in five online shoppers experienced at least one issue with a delivery last Christmas.
When he took office as the top federal prosecutor in Manhattan in late 2021, Damian Williams pledged to prioritize "rooting out corruption in our financial markets." Now, with the fraud charges filed earlier this week against Sam Bankman-Fried, the founder of the bankrupt FTX exchange, Williams has further solidified his office's growing role in prosecuting financial crimes involving cryptocurrency, according to interviews with a half-dozen former prosecutors. "Every U.S. attorney is defined in the public eye by some of the biggest cases that they bring," said Harry Sandick, a partner at law firm Patterson Belknap and former Manhattan federal prosecutor.
Amazon generated an estimated 709 million pounds of plastic packaging waste in 2021, up 18% from 2020, according to a new report. The giant retailer said Oceana’s numbers are exaggerated and based on a lot of assumptions.
Amazon.Com, Inc (NASDAQ: AMZN) shelved the joining for some university graduates set to join the company in May, blaming the "macroeconomic environment. Amazon postponed the students' joining until the end of 2023 and doled out a one-off payment of $13,000, the Financial Times reports. One of the students was likely to join Amazon's campus in Sunnyvale, California, home to Lab126. Also Read: Amazon's Cloud Eyes More Staff in 2023, Remain Invested In More Data Centers Lab126, where Amazon develop
Consumers are back in shopping centers as traditional retail stocks rebound on Wall Street while outperforming Amazon, Overstock and eBay.
(Bloomberg) — The US Senate voted to ban the hugely popular TikTok video-sharing app from all government-issued phones and other devices as the Biden administration considers restrictions on the Chinese-owned platform.Most Read from BloombergIs Putin Finally Getting Smart About His Ukraine Disaster?Elon Musk’s Tesla Share Sales Approach the $40 Billion MarkPowell Says Fed Still Has a ‘Ways to Go’ After Half-Point HikeDollar Rallies as Risk-Off Tone Takes Stocks Lower: Markets WrapThe measure, w
The locations are a departure from the company's early Go stores, but signal the company is serious about bringing its physical retail into more suburban areas.
(Bloomberg) — The US seized dozens of internet domains and charged six people in a sting intended to bring down a network of cyberattack-for-hire services, the Department of Justice announced on Wednesday.Most Read from BloombergIs Putin Finally Getting Smart About His Ukraine Disaster?Elon Musk’s Tesla Share Sales Approach the $40 Billion MarkPowell Says Fed Still Has a ‘Ways to Go’ After Half-Point HikeDollar Rallies as Risk-Off Tone Takes Stocks Lower: Markets WrapIn all, the US obtained a c
There are secular growth drivers of the Analog/Mixed Signal Semiconductor industry with near-term uncertainty leading to an attractive valuation. ADI, MTSI, and MCHP are worth exploring.
U.S. stock indexes closed sharply lower on Thursday, with each of the major averages suffering their biggest daily percentage drop in weeks, as fears intensified that the Federal Reserve's battle against inflation using aggressive interest rate hikes could lead to a recession. The U.S. central bank hiked rates by 50 basis points (bps) on Wednesday as was widely expected, downsizing from the consecutive 75 bps hikes at its prior four meetings, but Fed Chair Jerome Powell warned recent signs of inflation were not enough to convince Fed the battle against rising prices had been won. The Fed projected continued rate hikes to above 5% in 2023, a level not seen since a steep economic downturn in 2007.
The Thrifty Food Plan (TFP) is used to determine SNAP benefit amounts, which vary by household size. According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), benefit amounts are updated yearly based on…
MUMBAI (Reuters) -Amazon and Walmart's Flipkart have been issued with notices by an Indian government body asking why dangerous acids are available on their sites after a schoolgirl was the victim of an acid attack. The Delhi Commission for Women, a local body that looks after women's issues, said in the notice that it had learned the accused in the acid attack had bought the material from Walmart's Flipkart. Hours after the notice was issued, Flipkart said it had blacklisted the seller of the product used, and was extending all support to authorities in their investigation.
(Bloomberg) — Headspace Health, the maker of a popular meditation and mental-health mobile app, cut about 50 jobs, or 4% of its workforce, the latest internet startup to scale back as funding dries up and economic growth decelerates.Most Read from BloombergIs Putin Finally Getting Smart About His Ukraine Disaster?Elon Musk’s Tesla Share Sales Approach the $40 Billion MarkPowell Says Fed Still Has a ‘Ways to Go’ After Half-Point HikeDollar Rallies as Risk-Off Tone Takes Stocks Lower: Markets Wra
(Bloomberg) — Inc.’s devices chief said the company remains committed to building out the Alexa ecosystem despite job cuts in the once fast-growing division. Most Read from BloombergIs Putin Finally Getting Smart About His Ukraine Disaster?Elon Musk’s Tesla Share Sales Approach the $40 Billion MarkPowell Says Fed Still Has a ‘Ways to Go’ After Half-Point HikeDollar Rallies as Risk-Off Tone Takes Stocks Lower: Markets WrapWhen Amazon last month initiated its biggest-ever round of layo
Every investor in Entravision Communications Corporation ( NYSE:EVC ) should be aware of the most powerful shareholder…
The bottom line from the Covid era: Supply chains that are overly dependent on China are unreliable, write Tinglong Dai and Christopher S. Tang.
Two police officers in coastal Mississippi were shot and killed early Wednesday by a woman who they had talked to for nearly 30 minutes in a motel parking lot, authorities said. Amy Anderson, 43, was sitting in a parked SUV with a female child when the officers were sent to the parking lot of a Motel 6 in Bay St. Louis around 4:30 a.m. on a welfare check, the Mississippi Department of Public Safety said in a statement. Bay St. Louis Police Sgt. Steven Robin and officer Branden Estorffe spoke to Anderson for nearly a half-hour before she fired at them while sitting in the vehicle, investigators said.
Nikola Corp founder Trevor Milton asked a judge in New York on Thursday to overturn his conviction on charges of defrauding investors in the electric vehicle company, saying a juror who decided the case concealed her bias against the ultrawealthy. Milton told U.S. District Judge Edgardo Ramos in court papers that the juror's Twitter and Facebook pages were "riddled with attacks on wealthy executives" despite denying during jury selection that she used social media. A Manhattan federal jury convicted Milton at a trial in October, after prosecutors said Milton, 40, became a billionaire by lying to investors about the electric- and hydrogen-powered truck maker's technology starting in November 2019.
A Miami firefighter who is under investigation and has lost his job, said he had no regrets after video captured him punching a handcuffed patient in October.